Repository logo
  • English
  • 中文
  • Log In
    New user? Click here to register.Have you forgotten your password?
Repository logo
    Communities & Collections
    Research Outputs
    Fundings & Projects
    People
    Organizations
    Statistics
  • English
  • 中文
  • Log In
    New user? Click here to register.Have you forgotten your password?
  1. Home
  2. College of Medicine /醫學院
  3. Institute of Medicine/醫學研究所
  4. 經皮諾利式鋼釘固定和鉤狀骨板固定兩種手術方式治療肩峰鎖骨關節脫臼之比較
 
  • Details
Options

經皮諾利式鋼釘固定和鉤狀骨板固定兩種手術方式治療肩峰鎖骨關節脫臼之比較

Date Issued
2022
Author(s)
吳羽穎  
Yu-Ying Wu  
Advisor
周明智  
Ming-Chih Chou  
URI
https://handle.ncl.edu.tw/11296/zd95a5
https://scholars.csmu.edu.tw/handle/123456789/36669
Abstract
研究目的肩峰鎖骨關節脫臼是最常見肩部傷害導致的損傷,大約佔了肩帶脫臼比例中的21%,目前對於肩峰鎖骨關節脫臼的手術治療方式大多數醫師會使用鉤狀骨板作為固定的工具,但這種治療方式可能會有一些併發症產生,包括肩峰侵蝕、肩部夾擠、鎖骨骨折與肩峰鎖骨關節退化。因使我們嘗試使用經皮諾利式鋼釘固定來做為第三及第五型肩峰鎖骨關節脫臼的治療方式,假設經皮諾利式鋼釘能比鉤狀骨板固定有更少的併發症,並且可以維持喙鎖韌帶及肩峰鎖骨韌帶修復時的穩定,得到術後滿意的肩關節功能恢復。研究方法我們回溯性的選取本院2013年2月到2020年10月之間被診斷第三、五型肩峰鎖骨關節脫臼接受手術鉤狀骨板固定或經皮諾利式鋼釘固定的48個病患,探討比較使用鉤狀鋼板固定(31人)及諾利式鋼釘固定(18人)的術後肩關節功能、影像學評估以、併發症與醫療花費。有一位病患一開始接受諾利式鋼釘固定,但追蹤時發現有再度脫臼情形,因而接受鉤狀骨板固定。這個病患接受兩種手術,因此其病歷資料被分別放在兩組之中分析。研究結果結果顯示兩種固定方法對肩關節臨床分數而言有類似的滿意度(92.94 ± 4.97 v.s. 92.00 ± 5.88, p = 0.821)。(p<0.001)。在併發症的部分,諾利式鋼釘固定組明顯比鉤狀骨板固定有更少的併發症(p < 0.05)。另外在傷口長度、手術時間、內固定物存在時間以及住院天數等,諾利式鋼釘固定明顯優於鉤狀鋼板(p<0.001)。此外我們在術後影像學評估也發現鉤狀骨板手術後肩峰侵蝕的發生過度的矯正,跟肩峰鎖骨關節過度的矯正有關。結論與建議對於肩關節功能臨床分數而言,兩種固定方法有類似的滿意度,但使用諾利式鋼釘固定組有較低的併發症機率,除此之外也有較小的手術傷口、較短的手術時間、較早可取出內固定物,較少住院天數與較便宜的內固定物。因此本研究認為使用諾利式鋼釘治療肩峰鎖骨關節脫臼是一個簡單可行且具有經濟效益的治療方式。
ObjectiveAcromioclavicular (AC) disruptions are the most common shoulder injury, accounting for 21% of dislocations in the shoulder girdle. Hook plate fixation has been extensively applied for the treatment of acromioclavicular joint(ACJ) dislocation. However, various complications have been reported after surgery, such as acromion erosion, shoulder impingement, clavicle fracture, and osteoarthritis of ACJ. The aim of this study was to determine the long-term radiological and clinical differences between hook plate fixation and percutaneous Knowles pin fixation in the surgical treatment of acute Rockwood types III and V dislocations.Material and methodA single-institutional retrospective study was conducted to analyze 48 patients with type III and type V ACJ dislocation who underwent hook plate fixation or percutaneous Knowles pin fixation between February 2014 and October 2020 at our hospital. 31 patients received hook plate fixation and 18 patients received percutaneous Knowles pin fixation. Clinical functional scores, radiographic assessments, complications, and medical costs were recorded and compared. One of the patients in the Knowles pin group was found with secondary dislocation and then received hook plate fixation. Due to the fact that two types of surgery were performed in one patient, we recorded his clinical data in each group.ResultsPercutaneous fixation of Knowles pins had equally satisfactory effects on clinical shoulder scores compared to hook plate fixation (92.94 ± 4.97 vs 92.00 ± 5.88, p = 0.821). Furthermore, Knowles pin fixation significantly reduced the rate of complications.(p < 0.001). In addition, compared to the hook plate fixation, the percutaneous Knowles pin fixation decreased surgical wound length, operation time, blood loss, and length of hospitalization.(p < 0.01). We also note that overcorrection of the hook plate has a positive relationship with rebound after implant removal, and it could be related to increasing the risk of acromion erosion.ConclusionPercutaneous Knowles pin fixation is an effective surgical method for acute ACJ dislocation with a similar Constant score compared to hook plate fixation. Relative low risk of complications, decreased wound length, operation time, implant duration, and hospitalization day were noted in Knowles pin fixation. In addition, it is a cost-effective operative method.
Subjects
肩峰鎖骨關節脫臼
諾利式鋼釘
鉤狀骨板
肩峰侵蝕
acrominoclavicular dislocation
Knowles pin
Hook plate
acromion erosion
Type
thesis
File(s)
No Thumbnail Available
Name

110CSMU5534037-001.pdf

Size

1.72 MB

Format

Adobe PDF

Checksum

(MD5):89a5a060135c8670f8ceaa5eb74ab576

Make it your own

DSpace-CRIS can be extensively configured to meet your needs. Decide which information need to be collected and available with fine-grained security. Start updating the theme to match your Institution's web identity.

Built with DSpace-CRIS software - Extension maintained and optimized by 4Science

  • Cookie settings
  • Privacy policy
  • End User Agreement
  • Send Feedback