Options
重力垂直感知設備之心理計量特性與設備間的差異
Date Issued
2022
Author(s)
胡逸棣
Yi-Ti Hu
Advisor
林志峰
Abstract
背景:視覺和本體感覺對於維持正確姿勢、提供身體定向,具有很大的貢獻。臨床上測量本體感覺異常的方法具有很多種,而其中,重力垂直感知是我們關注的測量方式,但往往測量重力垂直本體感覺需要昂貴的設備,並且需要專業人員執行,導致在臨床上並不常見,設備花費的多寡,也會影響到醫療單位使用設備的普及率,是一個值得注意的問題。目的:1.設計一個便宜且方便使用的工具,以健康年輕人族群進行試驗,來驗證這個工具是否有良好的信度,提供未來臨床使用。2.先前的研究顯示健康年輕族群,在靜態的情境下,測量坐姿與站姿的重力感知,兩者並無差異,利用此次開發的設備看能否重現與先前研究相同的結果。3. 利用此次開發的設備,比較不同設備對於重力垂直感知評估是否具有差異。研究設計:便利取樣研究。材料與方法:本研究採便宜樣本收案,共收案32位受測者(16男16女),平均年齡21.37歲。使用數位式角度計、紅光雷射投影器、與3D列印製作簡易測量工具。1. 視覺感知(坐姿與站姿)。2. 姿勢感知(坐姿與站姿)。3. 觸覺水平感知(坐姿與站姿)。4. 觸覺感知(坐姿與站姿)。每一測試均分順時鐘與逆時鐘方向執行且重複測試3次,每次間隔1分鐘,使用級內相關係數(Intraclass correction coefficient, ICC)計算測試的信度。結果:總共收入32位受測者,亞當測試陽性的受測者(n = 7),排除後剩25位健康年輕受測者(13男12女),平均年齡21.20歲。1.視覺垂直本體感覺(SVP):坐姿(ICC=0.699/0.793,Mean=0.53 ± 0.21/0.62 ± 0.36,順時鐘/逆時鐘);站姿(ICC=0.794/0.724,Mean=0.54 ± 0.26/0.60 ± 0.25)。2.姿勢垂直本體感覺(SPP):坐姿睜眼(ICC=0.767/0.773,Mean=2.69 ± 1.45/1.98 ± 1.02);坐姿閉眼(ICC=0.762/0.868,Mean=3.15 ± 1.55/3.59 ± 1.95);站姿睜眼(ICC=0.945/0.888,Mean=2.21 ± 2.35/2.12 ± 1.40);站姿閉眼(ICC=0.886/0.700,Mean=2.57 ± 2.37/2.77 ± 1.36)。3.觸覺水平本體感覺(SHPH):坐姿睜眼(ICC=0.781/0.789,Mean=0.83 ± 0.55/0.65 ± 0.40);坐姿閉眼(ICC=0.891/0.867,Mean=4.42 ± 3.11/4.54 ± 2.98);站姿睜眼(ICC=0.737/0.787,Mean=0.80 ± 0.48/0.56 ± 0.36);站姿閉眼(ICC=0.612/0.897,Mean=2.92 ± 1.50/3.92 ± 3.31)。4.觸覺垂直本體感覺(SHPV):坐姿睜眼(ICC=0.791/0.932,Mean=0.98 ± 0.51/1.13 ± 0.75);坐姿閉眼(ICC=0.818/0.578,Mean=5.06 ± 3.79/4.23 ± 2.07);站姿睜眼(ICC=0.775/0.771,Mean=0.88 ± 0.53/0.87 ± 0.55);站姿閉眼(ICC=0.707/0.817,Mean=5.07 ± 3.36/4.87 ± 2.90)。坐姿與站姿組間比較:視覺感知(p = 0.782)、姿勢感知(p = 0.101)、觸覺感知(p = 0.331)。設備間差異:視覺感知與姿勢感知(p<0.05);觸覺感知與姿勢感知(p<0.05)。討論:1. 本研究顯示健康年輕人對於重力本體感覺的測量,在各個項目都有良好的可信度。表示本研究設計的工具具有良的可信度。只有在姿勢感知中,有一測試項目結果未大於0.7(ICC= 0.699),可能因個案數的不足,未來建議可以收入更多的樣本數。2.不管在任何任務情境,靜態的坐姿與站姿沒有差異。3.。SVP與SPP兩者之間具有差異;SVP 與SHP兩者之間具有差異。結論:此開發的工具具有良好的信度,未來進行效度驗證,可作為一個成本相對較低、方便攜帶且易於操作的評估工具。重現了與之前研究相同的結果,即在健康年輕族群,靜態的坐姿與站姿比較,不管在視感知、姿勢感知或觸覺感知中,坐姿與站姿在重力感知方面並無顯著差異。
Background: Visual and proprioception have a great contribution to maintain correct posture and body orientation. There are plenty types of quantitative measurements to evaluate proprioception. One of many measurements, gravitational vertical perception is the main measurement that we focus on. However, those quantitative measurements required expensive, stationary equipment and experienced operators to operate. Furthermore, the cost of equipment will also affect the penetration rate of equipment used by medical units, which is a problem that worth noting. Purpose: 1. Design a relatively low-cost, easy-to-carry, easy-to-operate device and experiment it with healthy young population to test whether this device have a good reliability or not. 2. Previous research reported that healthy young population weather in sitting or standing position, there was no significant difference between two conditions in the static un-tilted situation (standing surface)。Our purpose is to use our developed equipment to see if the difference between sitting and standing condition can be reproduced. 3. Compare different equipment to see if there is a different between each equipment. Study design: Convenience sampling research. Materials and methods: 32 (16/16, male/female) healthy young adults (mean age: 21.37 y/o) were recruited in this study. Adam forward banding test positive (n=7),25 healthy subjects were remained. Our method used self-made devices (3D printed project, digital protractor, and laser) to capture Subjective visual perception (SVP), Subjective postural perception (SPP), and Subjective haptic perception (SHP). Result: 1. Subjective visual perception (SVP): sitting (ICC=0.699/0.793, mean angle= 0.53 ± 0.21/0.62 ± 0.36, clockwise/counterclockwise), standing (ICC=0.794/0.724, mean angle= 0.54 ± 0.26/0.60 ± 0.25)2.Subjective posture vertical (SPP):sitting with eye open (EO) (ICC=0.767/0.773, mean angle=2.69 ± 1.45/1.98 ± 1.02), sitting with eye close (ICC=0.762/0.868, mean angle= 3.15 ± 1.55/3.59 ± 1.95), standing with EO (ICC=0.945/0.888, mean angle= 2.21 ± 2.35/2.12 ± 1.40), standing with EC (ICC=0.886/0.700, mean angle= 2.57 ± 2.37/2.77 ± 1.36). 3.Subject haptic perception (SHP): 1. Horizontal: sitting with EO (ICC=0.781/0.789, mean angle=0.83 ± 0.55/0.65 ± 0.40), sitting with EC (ICC=0.891/0.867, mean angle= 4.42 ± 3.11/4.54 ± 2.98), standing with EO (ICC=0.737/0.787, mean angle= 0.80 ± 0.48/0.56 ± 0.36), standing with EC (ICC=0.612/0.897, mean angle= 2.92 ± 1.50/3.92 ± 3.31). 2.Vertical: Sitting EO (ICC=0.791/0.932, mean angle= 0.98 ± 0.51/1.13 ± 0.75), Sitting with EC (ICC=0.818/0.578, mean angle= 5.06 ± 3.79/4.23 ± 2.07). Standing with EO (ICC=0.775/0.77, mean angle= 0.88 ± 0.53/0.87 ± 0.55), Standing with EC (ICC=0.707/0.817, mean angle= 5.07 ± 3.36/4.87 ± 2.90).Sitting and standing comparison: 1.SVP (p=782) 2. SPP: (p= 0.101) 3.SHPV: EO (p= 0.331). Discussion: 1. Our research demonstrates that healthy young adult in gravitational vertical proprioception measurement, in almost every item have a good reliability. This is showing that our development device has a good reliability, but in SVP test, it has one item didn’t greater than 0.7. This problem might be a shortage of samples due to the criteria of our study. We suggest that future studies should accept larger sample sizes. 2.Comparison between sitting and standing: There is no different between SVP, SPP, SHP in static condition. Previous research has shown that there is no difference between sitting and standing in a static state. And so, our study has the same outcome as previous. 3. There is different between SVP with SPP and SVP with SHP. Conclusion: This developed device have a good reliability. After testing the validation, it can consider as a relatively low-cost, convenient to carry and easy to operate devices. We reproduced the same outcome with the previous study that there is no difference between sitting and standing in static gravitational proprioception in healthy young population. And there is a significant difference between SPP with SVP and SHP with SVP in healthy young population. To the future studies, we suggest using this device to compare with other populations. For example: stroke, vestibular disorder or scoliosis population. In those population, gravitational perception is a highly important part for those people to maintain posture.
Subjects
健康年輕人
重力
垂直感知
工具信度
healthy young adult
vertical proprioception
gravitational
reliability
Type
thesis
File(s)
No Thumbnail Available
Name
110CSMU5595004-001.pdf
Size
5.27 MB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum
(MD5):995e47bb240a2cfe170702cadecc5719