李宣信;廖勇柏Lee, Shiuan-Shinn;Liaw, Yung-Po賴怡伶Lai, Yi-LingYi-LingLai公共衛生學系博士班2026-02-102025-01-2020252025-01-07https://handle.ncl.edu.tw/11296/kr9pf6https://scholars.csmu.edu.tw/handle/123456789/5342背景:從過去30年護理人力學術焦點演化分析的結果得知,全球人口老化,以及少子化之影響,人力供給與醫療需求可能帶來巨大的變動。但從護理人力知識軌跡鮮少從供給及需求的視角探究護理人力。是故,本論文將以過去護理人力發展知識脈絡軌跡為基礎,從需求面及供給面的觀點來探究台灣護理人力之發展,期為台灣或全球護理人力大缺工議題找到可能的解方或新的研究方向。方法:本論文的文獻回顧研究採主路徑分析法檢視護理人力研究發展的知識脈絡。需求面的研究內容,採用觀察性時間數列方法,並從台灣政府管理的多個數據庫中收集。運用時間變動向量自我回歸模型(TVP-VAR)結和時間變動衝擊反應分析(TV-IRA)、自我回歸分佈滯後模型(ARDL)作為研究方法,探討年齡分佈與護理人員配置政策效力之間的關聯性;供給面的的研究內容則利用雙分量回歸模型(QQRM)來分析數據,而研究資料來自台灣護理師會全聯會護理統計數據以及台灣主計處的總體經濟統計數據庫的各項社會經濟變數。結果:需求面結果顯示,護理人員配置變化對住院病人出院後14天內非計劃再住院率的時間變動衝擊反應,在各層級醫院中存在正向關聯。然而,隨著人口老化,醫院護理人員配置政策的有效性鈍化,此在醫學中心和區域醫院中尤為明顯。從供給面分析結果為,護理人員薪資對總執業率以及年輕和年長護理人員的執業率整體上有正影響,但對中年護理人員的執業率則是負影響。護理人員薪資與總執業率及年輕護理人員執業率的中、高分位數呈現正相關,但對年輕護理人員執業率的低分位數呈現負相關。相反地,護理人員薪資對中年護理人員執業率的影響持續為負。護理人員薪資對年長護理人員執業率低分位數有正影響,但對年長護理人員執業率中和高分位數的負影響也被確定。護理人員薪資的低分位數與年輕護理人員的執業率呈現負相關,但護理人員薪資的低分位數與中年和年長護理人員的執業率呈現正相關。護理人員薪資的中分位數與中年和年長護理人員的執業率呈現負相關,但護理人員薪資的中分位數與年輕護理人員的執業率呈現正相關,而護理人員薪資的高分位數則與所有年齡組的執業率持續呈現正相關。結論:從需求面而言,政策制定者應建立較低的法定病患與護理人員比率,並依實際的各層級醫院人力所需,改善醫院護理人員配置以提升住院醫療品質。從供給面觀察到的護理人員薪資與護理人員執業之間的關係變化得出結論,僅僅提高護理人員的薪資可能無法有效改變護理人員就業的週期模式。因此,應實施旨在應對不同年齡組護理人員就業週期非經濟誘因性的干預措施,以確保其穩定性。Background:An analysis of the evolution of academic focus on nursing workforce issues over the past 30 years reveals that global demographic shifts, such as population aging and declining birth rates, are likely to cause significant changes in both workforce supply and healthcare demand. However, there is a lack of research exploring the nursing workforce from the dual perspectives of supply and demand. Therefore, this study aims to investigate the development of Taiwan’s nursing workforce from these perspectives based on the historical trajectory of nursing workforce knowledge. The goal is to identify potential solutions or new research directions for addressing the critical shortage of nursing staff in Taiwan and globally.Methods:This literature review employs path analysis to examine the knowledge trajectory of nursing workforce research. Analysis of the demand side utilizes an observational time series approach, drawing data from various government-managed databases in Taiwan. The study applies a Time-Varying Parameter Vector Autoregressive (TVP-VAR) model combined with a Time-Varying Impulse Response Analysis (TV-IRA) and an Autoregressive Distributed Lag (ARDL) model to explore the relationship between age distribution and the effectiveness of nursing staff allocation policies. On the supply side, this study uses a Quantile–Quantile Regression Model (QQRM) to analyze data obtained from the Taiwan Nurses Association's nursing statistics and the Directorate- General of Budget, Accounting and Statistics, Executive Yuan, R.O.C.(Taiwan) economic and socioeconomic data.Results:The demand-side analysis indicates a positive relationship between changes in nursing staff allocation and the time-varying impulse response of unplanned readmission rates within 14 days after discharge across all hospital levels. However, the effectiveness of nursing staff allocation policies declines with population aging, particularly in medical centers and regional hospitals. On the supply side, the results show that nursing wages have a positive impact on the overall employment rate and the employment rate of both younger and older nurses, but a negative impact on the employment rate of middle-aged nurses. The correlation between nursing wages and employment rates for younger nurses is positive at higher quantiles and negative at lower quantiles. Conversely, the relationship between nursing wages and middle-aged nurses' employment rates remains negative. Furthermore, nursing wages are positively associated with employment rates for older nurses at lower quantiles but negatively associated with employment rates at the median and higher quantiles. A lower quantile of nursing wages is negatively correlated with the employment rate of younger nurses, but positively correlated with the employment rate of middle-aged and older nurses. The median quantile of nursing wages is negatively correlated with employment rates for middle-aged and older nurses, but positively correlated with employment rates for younger nurses. Finally, a higher quantile of nursing wages shows a positive correlation with employment rates across all age groups.Conclusion:From the demand side, policymakers should establish a lower statutory nurse-to-patient ratio and adjust nursing staff allocation based on the actual needs at different hospital levels to improve the quality of inpatient care. Regarding the supply side, the analysis of the relationship between nursing wages and employment suggests that simply increasing nursing salaries may not be sufficient to effectively change the cyclical patterns of nursing employment. Therefore, interventions targeting non-economic factors affecting employment cycles for different age groups of nurses should be implemented to ensure the stability of the nursing workforce.護理人力文獻計量nurse staffingnurse workforcenurse to patient ratio台灣護理人力配置政策實證研究:從需求面、供給面與文獻計量的洞察thesis